Columbus Crew advanced in the US Open Cup with a 1–0 victory over New York City FC, controlling proceedings through a dominant first-half performance built on possession and volume. The hosts dominated with 60 per cent possession and 14 shots, eight of which found the target, while NYCFC managed just five attempts and none on goal. Maximilian Arfsten's solitary strike proved decisive in a match where Columbus's 4–4–2 setup suffocated the visitors' 4–3–3 formation. NYCFC's goalkeeper made eight saves but could not prevent the breakthrough, posting an 87.5 per cent save percentage in a largely defensive outing. The Crew's efficiency in front of goal and territorial dominance secured progression, while the visitors offered little attacking threat throughout. Columbus's cup credentials strengthened with this composed performance.